Choice, a Privilege of Youth!

An historical essay and short film script by Malcolm J. Brenner

Homegrown cannabis under a grow lamp during photo period, when the plant receives continuous light. ©2022 Malcolm J. Brenner

You don’t understand, how can you possibly understand? Society has changed so much, and everything is different! Now, weed is widely accepted as a medicinal herb, it’s in everything from blunts to unguents to smoothies! Let me use a recent experience to try to explain to you what SMOKING WEED was like, ‘way back in 1970, and why your GRANDPARENTS still want to draw the curtains and light a stick of incense when they spark:

SARASOTA, FL. — My brother Hugh, 17, his friend Gary and two girls, all seniors in high school, decided to drive out to Myakka State Park in Gary’s beater car and spend a day communing with Mother Nature — the green, flammable kind, in addition to the trees, birds, squirrels and alligators. Because Gary had a prior for possession, my brother stuck the couple of joints they’d rolled in his sock. They were going to smoke them when they got good and ready!

They got to park, found an open field and began to just run around, play, turn cartwheels, do somersaults — an unusual, but typical, outburst of teenage energy and enthusiasm, and an entirely natural one, because they hadn’t yet set flame to Zig-Zag. Their behavior, however, caught the attention of a State Park Ranger, who monitored them through binoculars from the nearby woods and decided they must all be tripping on that LySolic acid Dramatic-us, or whatever it was young people did back then. You know, Commie stuff! They were probably draft dodgers, at least the boys, and the girls — well, the girls were obviously the kind of young ladies who would sleep with draft dodgers! So he did the natural thing, pulled out his shotgun, stepped out of the shadows of the cabbage palms and yelled “FREEZE! YOU’RE UNDER ARREST, HIPPIE SCUM!”

Or words to that effect.

Long story short, it was my brother who ended up staying in the Sarasota Juvenile Detention Center at the county taxpayers’ expense that night. Our mother was attending a adult degree program at Goddard College in Plainfield, Vermont, so I went to the JDC and give Hugh a big hug, which startled him almost as much as the park ranger had! I think he’d been more expecting a punch in the jaw from me — but not for using pot, hell no! The one thing I am not is a hypocrite, and I smoked at least as much as he did!

FOR GETTING CAUGHT, THE STUPID LITTLE SEWER-SNOID!

I mean, they could have appointed a lookout! Or Hugh could have eaten the joints (I note that it’s much more difficult to dispose of a metal or glass pipe this way, although silicon would be okay, if somewhat rubbery), or even wrapped them in plastic wrap beforehand and stuck them up his ass! (An early member of environmental organization Greenpeace once saved an irreplaceable roll of 35mm film documenting French police brutality by hiding it in her vagina. True story!) There were JUST ALL KINDS OF WAYS OF HANDLING THAT SITUATION that my brother and his fellow-travelers did not employ, probably because they, like most people, believed the oldest lie in the world:

IT CAN’T HAPPEN TO ME!

Why is this statement a lie?

Simple: BECAUSE IT ALWAYS HAPPENS TO US! ALL OF US, NO EXCEPTIONS. WE FUCK-UP, AND WE DIE. TWO ABSOLUTE TRUTHS OF EXISTENCE! WE’RE ALL HUMAN, ALL MORTAL. PERIOD, CASE CLOSED.

Quit worrying about Hugh! Other than that one night in jail, he never served any time. Because he was 17 and a minor, the judge just sentenced him to 6 months’ probation, and the arrest was expunged from his record when he turned 18. As our mother often said of him, “He could fall in a barrel of shit, and come up golden!” She had a very colorful vocabulary, did me Yorkshire mum!

TIME PASSES… 1980, 1990, 2000, 2010, 2020…

FADE IN: RECENT PAST, APRIL, 2023, INTERIOR MALCOLM’S HOUSE, PORT CHARLOTTE.

Pre-dawn lighting. MALCOLM’S living room is dark, and a black dog, EPIC, unseen at first, is barking. MALCOLM, naked, cursing at the dog, ENTERS from the BEDROOM and crosses to the window. Parting the blinds, he squints outside.

CUTAWAY: A silver truck is parked on the grass in front of Malcolm’s house. The engine isn’t running, and the cab is empty.

MALCOLM (to dog): “You bitch, you woke me up for THAT? Fuuuuucccckk…” He stumbles back to the bedroom, closing the door behind him.

DISSOLVE TO: The same door, later that morning, better lit. MALCOLM steps out, wrapping a tattered gingham bathrobe around himself and tying the frayed sash. He moves to the window and begins opening the blinds.

REACTION SHOT: EXT. LOOKING IN THROUGH WINDOW at MALCOLM. We see the truck, still on his lawn, reflected in the glass.

MALCOLM: “Fuck! Is that fucking thing still here? Fuck it…” He rubs his chin thoughtfully, looks up at the truck.

CAMERA PANS EXT. TRUCK, showing it’s in nice shape! Clean, no dents, looks like it’s owned by somebody who values it.

INT. MALCOLM at the WINDOW. He drops his hand from his chin, turns from window.

MALCOLM: “Ahh, I won’t call the cops, not yet! That truck’s not abandoned, it’s too nice! I’m sure somebody will be here with a tow truck soon, in the meantime… (YELLS) HEY EPIC! DO YOU WANT TO GO FOR A WALK?”

INT. CLOSE UP: EPIC emerges from the bedroom, carrying her leash folded-up in her mouth, wagging her tail in eager anticipation.

DISSOLVE TO: EPIC and MALCOLM, now dressed in camo shorts and T-shirt, walking on the sidewalk.

DISSOLVE TO: MALCOLM and EPIC return to his front door. CAMERA PANS to show truck still there. CAMERA PANS BACK to Malcolm.

MALCOLM: “Damn, still there! Well, time for our morning smoke, Epic. (He unlocks the front door.) Care to join me?”

EPIC: (Eagerly) “WOOF!” (They both step inside. Door closes.)

JUMP CUT TO: Door opens again and Malcolm steps out with a tray in his hand. On it are some tasty looking buds, rolling papers, a grinder and other accessories. CAMERA PANS to the silver truck just as a tow truck pulls up alongside it. The TOW TRUCK DRIVER gets out and begins to prep the silver truck to be towed.

EXT. DAY MALCOLM, still at the door, watching the tow truck driver at work. DOG NOISES from inside.

MALCOLM: (Turns back inside, yells to dog, offscreen ) “If I’ve told you once, Epic, I’ve told you a thousand times, don’t be greedy! Take small tokes, not big ones! You can hold it better that way!”

DOG HOWLS. MALCOLM shakes head, CAMERA FOLLOWS him as he closes the door and sits in a chair at a patio table, puts the tray of weed down on the table, begins to load the grinder.

REVERSE ANGLE on MALCOLM’S face, intent on his work. He looks up at a noise of a truck door opening. CAMERA ZOOMS BACK to show a passenger get out of the tow truck’s side door, dressed all in black with a lizard-skin belt. He is a 20-something HIPSTER with a scraggly beard and hair pulled back in a bun. He walks around to the front of the truck and bends down.

CLOSE UP: The tire HIPSTER is looking at is flat. Very, very flat. As flat as your sister when she was 11.

MALCOLM looks up from rolling a joint.

REVERSE ANGLE over MALCOLM’S shoulder showing the HIPSTER sighing over the flat tire.

Holding the freshly rolled reefer in one hand, MALCOLM gets up and begins to walk toward the HIPSTER.

HIPSTER looks up, notices MALCOLM approaching.

MALCOLM (Stopping beside HIPSTER): “Truck troubles?”

HIPSTER: “Yeah, I got troubles all right! I took the truck out last night, ran over a bottle or something, it ripped the tire all to shreds! So then I go to put the spare on, and guess what?”

MALCOLM: (Pensively) “It was flat too?”

HIPSTER: (Somewhat derisively) “No shit, Sherlock! So now we gotta take it into the shop, two new tires and probably a rim to boot! It’s going to cost a bundle!”

THE TOW TRUCK DRIVER begins to winch the HIPSTER’S truck up the ramp.

MALCOLM: “I feel sorry for you!” (Raises joint to lips, lights it, puffs a couple of times.) “Seems like Murphy’s Law in action! Well, here, maybe this will make you feel better…” (MALCOLM proffers the joint to the HIPSTER, who hesitates, for some reason. MALCOLM looks him up and down. NOISES from tow truck. Yeah, he’s a hipster, all right!)

MALCOLM: “You do indulge, don’t you?”

HIPSTER: “Uhhhh… yeah.”

MALCOLM: “Go on, I’ve got a cannabis card! I just bought this yesterday from my favorite pot shop, it’s fine sensi, brother!”

HIPSTER: “Is that Sativa or Indica?”

MALCOLM’S lower jaw falls open. He cannot believe what he’s just heard!

MALCOLM: (Angrily) “What do you care, buddy? It’s good dope, do you want a hit or not?”

HIPSTER: “You don’t know?”

MALCOLM: “It’s a hybrid… just take a damn hit, will you?” (Nervously, the HIPSTER takes the joint and tries to hit it, but it’s out. MALCOLM re-lights it for him, and the HIPSTER takes a quick, shallow hit, a real Bill Clinton hit, and passes the muggles back to Malcolm.

MALCOLM: “You know, back in my day, we didn’t ask what kind of dope it was, we were just so glad to…”

TOW TRUCK DRIVER (interrupting) “That does it, hey, you ready to go? Let’s roll!”

HIPSTER turns away from MALCOLM without a word and gets into the passenger side of the tow truck.

REFLECTION SHOT: MALCOLM framed by the tow truck’s outside mirror. It drives away, and the camera pans to MALCOLM’S face, the joint hanging from his lips. He squints after the truck, a Clint Eastwood scowl twisting his face.

MALCOLM: “I’ll be damned, he didn’t even say ‘Thank you!’ What a total turd!” (He inhales deeply and holds it, pondering humanity’s fate in a cold and uncaring cosmos. He slowly lets the smoke out his nostrils and looks up, glassy eyed, into the CAMERA, blinks a couple of times before speaking.

MALCOLM: “I ask you, Kids of Today, you who have grown up with so much privilege, what is this world coming to when you can can’t offer someone a hit of weed, without them demanding to know its’ lineage?”

MALCOLM looks down, takes another hit, turns around and begins to walk back toward his house. EPIC, off camera, HOWLS again.

MALCOLM (going toward front door): “Shut up, you damn dog, or I’ll fix your wagon!” He goes inside as the CAMERA ZOOMS BACK, revealing the tire tracks in MALCOLM’S front yard.

FADE OUT, end credits roll.

Above comic strip property of Universal Press Syndicate, ©1977 G. B. Trudeau, used without paying the insane $35 fee they demanded just to stick this in a blog post! So sue me, Gary, I want to see the snickering headlines on the New York Times when you try! My daughter owns everything I have, so nyah-nyah! Love your work, but take your $35 licensing fee and stick it where the moon don’t shine, baby! FAIR USE, FAIR USE!

Wake up, Dr. Irvine, wake up!

by Malcolm J. Brenner

Above: Portrait of Dr. Blair Irvine, courtesy GulfBase. I think he has the eyes of a sociopath, but hey, what the fuck do I know? I’m just some guy he used one morning as a TOXIC WASTE DUMP, and he thought he’d never hear from again. Wrong bet, Dr. Irvine, wrong bet. And yes, karma IS a bitch!

(Overnight, Dr. Blair Irvine, former director of the Sarasota Dolphin Research Project, changed his email address, so he couldn’t get any more emails from me like the one he received yesterday! Since this is the address at which the SDRP has received its donations, your next donation to them, if you make one [and I heartily endorse the SDRP, in spite of my personal feelings about Blair], don’t be surprised if it bounces back to your account. Unless you change it, which is troublesome, I admit. But hey, I didn’t tell him to change his freaking email address! I must have really gotten to him if he went to all that trouble! Well, as B. F. Skinner said, any acknowledgement, positive OR negative, can be perceived as a reward by the subject! It would have been better to DO NOTHING, but then again, I shouldn’t have to tell Dr. Irvine, who I am sure is a confirmed behaviorist, something that well-known and simple. Another chink in the armor of a “great scientist.” Yeah, right.)

WAKE UP, DR. IRVINE, WAKE UP!


IT’S TIME TO WAKE UP AND SMELL THE COFFEE! MR. BRENNER HAS POSTED HIS LETTER TO YOU ON malcolmbrenner.com/news, HIS WEB SITE! SO THE WHOLE WORLD NOW KNOWS HOW RUDE YOU WERE TO HIM, WHAT POOR CONTROL YOU HAVE OVER YOUR ANGER, AND HOW IMMATURE YOU SECRETLY ARE UNDER THAT FAÇADE OF EMOTIONAL CONTROL YOU SO PROUDLY SHOW THE WORLD! WASN’T IT NICE OF HIM TO WARN YOU? YOU SHOULD THANK HIM FOR BEING SO THOUGHTFUL, THERE WAS NO WARNING FROM YOU WHEN YOU TURNED ON HIM AND VERBALLY MUGGED HIM BECAUSE HE MENTIONED dr. Lilly’s DREAD NAME!


I HATE TO BE THE ONE TO TELL YOU, BUT MR. BRENNER SAYS HE IS PREPARED TO DO THIS EVERY MORNING, UNTIL YOU ANSWER HIS VERY REASONABLE QUESTION ABOUT WHY YOU TREATED RANDY WELLS SO NICELY, AND TREATED HIM LIKE SHIT. LIKE SOMETHING SCRAPED OFF YOUR SHOE, AFTER YOU WALKED AWAY.


YOU WERE VERY UNSCIENTIFIC, WHEN YOU LET YOUR PERSONAL FEELINGS ABOUT DR. LILLY OVERCOME WHATEVER TRIVIAL RESPECT YOU MAY HAVE HAD FOR MALCOLM AS A PERSON. YOUR INTEREST IN HIS WORK WAS VERY SHALLOW, AND MALCOLM SUSPECTS YOU ARE A SOCIOPATH, AND WONDERS HOW YOU COULD HAVE KEPT IT SECRET FOR SO LONG, IF YOU ARE. HE ALSO WONDERS HOW MANY OTHER UNHEARD-FROM PEOPLE ARE IN THE SAME POSITION HE IS, HAVING BECOME YOUR VICTIMS ON YOUR WAY TO THE TOP OF THE DOLPHIN WORLD?


OH, AND BTW, MALCOLM SAYS, “HEY, DO YOU OR THE U.S. NAVY OWN THE FILM OF SIMO? WHY DON’T YOU PUT IT ON THE WEB, DR. IRVINE, AND SHOW US WHAT A FUN TIME SIMO HAD, BEING CHASED BY AN AGGRESSIVE BULL SHARK! IS IT TRUE HE JUMPED OUT OF THE TANK TO AVOID IT?”

PUT THE FILMS ON THE WEB, AND LET US SEE FOR OURSELVES! I’LL BET YOU’VE STILL GOT A PRINT IN THE SDRP ARCHIVES, DON’T YOU? WHAT ARE YOU WAITING FOR? LET US BE THE ONES TO JUDGE WHAT A BRILLIANT SCIENTIST YOU ARE!


AND HERE’S A “VALID SCIENTIFIC EXPERIMENT” FOR YOU: WE PUT YOU, NAKED, IN A CIRCULAR TRACK YOU CAN’T GET OUT OF, AND WE RELEASE A 500-LB. (that’s 228.6 kilos, Malcolm knows you scientists like to do things in metric) TIGER INTO THE TRACK WITH YOU. BUT DON’T WORRY! WE’RE GOING TO GIVE YOU A ROCK TO THROW AT THE TIGER AS IT LEAPS ON YOU, AND IF YOU’RE A DEAD SHOT AND HIT THE TIGER RIGHT BETWEEN THE EYES, YOU’LL KILL IT! AND A BELL WILL GO OFF, AND YOU’LL GET A LOVELY FOOD PELLET AS A REWARD… THIS IS THE POSITION YOU PUT SIMO IN, ASSHOLE!


WHAT DO YOU LEARN ABOUT THE BEHAVIOR OF REAL DOLPHINS IN THE WILD WHEN YOU PUT A DOLPHIN IN A CIRCULAR TANK IT CAN’T ESCAPE FROM AND RELEASE A DOLPHIN-EATING SPECIES OF SHARK WITH IT?

NOTHING! YOU LEARN NOTHING ABOUT HOW A DOLPHIN BEHAVES IN THE WILD, WHERE IT HAS ROOM TO MANEUVER, TO GET UNDER THE SHARK, TO GET OUT OF ITS WAY, TO PROTECT ITS MATES AND YOUNG, OR REQUEST AID FROM ITS FELLOWS. BUT HEY, IT LOOKED GOOD TO THE O.N.R., AND GOT YOU A GENEROUS GRANT TO LIVE OFF OF! SO MALCOLM PAID FOR YOUR RESEARCH WITH HIS TAXES, TOO, ASSWIPE!


YOUR EXPERIMENT WAS A WORTHLESS PIECE OF SHIT, ALL IT TOLD THE U.S. NAVY IS HOW DOLPHINS BEHAVE IN A DONUT TANK, AND IF I AM NOT MISTAKEN, SUCH TANKS RARELY EXIST IN THE OPEN OCEAN. RELEASE THE FILMS AND PROVE MALCOLM WRONG!

LIKE I SAY, MALCOLM PLANS TO DO THIS EVERY MORNING, UNTIL YOU ANSWER HIS VERY, VERY REASONABLE AND RATIONAL QUESTION. MALCOLM SAYS HE CAN HOLD OUT LONGER THAN YOU CAN, OR UNTIL YOU CHANGE YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS, WHICH EVER COMES FIRST. AND MALCOLM WOULD HATE TO SEE YOU CHANGE IT, IT’S SUCH A BOTHER, YOU KNOW?


HAVE A FUCKED-UP DAY, DR. BLAIR! THIS HAS BEEN A WAKE-UP CALL FROM YOUR CONSCIENCE, AND IF IT’S HARD FOR YOU TO HEAR, DON’T BLAME ME, TURN UP YOUR HEARING AID YOU IDIOT, I’M SHOUTING AS LOUD AS I CAN! — dr. Blair Irvine’s conscience

An Open Letter to Dr. Blair Irvine, of the Sarasota Dolphin Research Program

The famous graphic artist R. Crumb expresses well my sentiments.

October 12, 2020

Dear Dr. Irvine,

Please forgive me for not reading your mind on that cold morning in March, 1971, when the head dolphin trainer at Floridaland, Robert Corbin, introduced us. I’m really, really sorry I said something that upset you so much, but only dolphins and a few other “lower” animals have given me the privilege of mental telepathy with them, and you just weren’t on my short list that morning. What can I say, at this late date, to make it right with you?

I’m sure you have long since forgotten the incident, but I haven’t, not only because you treated me like a non-person, but because you implied I was also very stupid, even though you had only met me for about 2 minutes. Let me jog your memory. You had run out of fish for Simo, the poor dolphin trapped in your worthless circular tank shark experiments. (More on that, and why your reputation is undeserved, later.) So you came down to Floridaland, where I was pursuing a independent study project at New College photographing the dolphins for a proposed book about them. And our paths chanced to cross outside the freezer shack, where Robert kept the fish.


Robert introduced us. I had, of course, heard of the experiment you were conducting for the US Navy at Mote Labs; everybody in town had heard about it, following your efforts to tag dolphins by burning holes in their dorsal fins and affixing plastic plaques, a rather crude and ineffective technique. Robert mentioned that I was a student who was very interested in dolphins. I told you a little bit about my project, and you seemed very enthusiastic about it at first. I remember you — oddly, in view of what happened — actually smiling, but it might just have been indigestion making you wince. A long time has passed, hasn’t it? Far too long for anybody except a real weirdo, like me, to still resent it, but I do.


Those first impressions, they are a bitch, aren’t they? It works both ways, Dr. Irvine. Both ways.


And then you asked the fateful question: “What books have you read?” If I had been able to read your mind then, I would not have given the answer that I did. Please believe me on this, is was the lack of clear, decipherable telepathy with you that ultimately let me down. I failed nobody but myself, there.


The answer I gave you was unfortunately honest, forthright and sincere. “Well, all of John Lilly’s stuff…” I started to say, preparing to explain how New College had a lousy library and it was difficult to get research papers there. But I never got a chance, because, as cold as it was that morning, the air between us froze, and you, in an instant, on a dime, in a New York minute, turned from a friendly, somewhat fatherly researcher with an interest in my work (admittedly a liberal arts approach to dolphins) into a lethal polar bear, moving in for the kill. The smile on your face disappeared, to be replaced in an instant with an expression of profound disgust, as if you had just stepped in dogshit — Great Dane dogshit. Something I’d said had obviously triggered you, and this was decades before pop psychologists began abusing that term. What could it be?

Could the mere mention of Dr. John C. Lilly’s name…? Could it? Really? How misfortunate for me, to mention the ONE NAME that would trigger you that morning! And how doubly misfortunate not to have read your fucking mind before hand, so that I’d be forewarned and not make the one mistake that would send you plunging off the end of the dock, dragging me with you! It was there, in the air over your head, clearly flashing red letters that said WHATEVER YOU DO, DON’T MENTION JOHN C. LILLY’S NAME TO THIS MAN, HE’LL FREAK OUT — and I chose to ignore it. Or I just didn’t see it. I certainly didn’t mean to provoke you, we’d only just met!


When you spoke, even your voice was different. There was an edge of threat or menace in it when you said “That man is either 50 years ahead of his time, or crazy, and most of us think he’s crazy! Good day!” By “us” I took it that you mean marine mammalogists at large — speaking for the community as a whole, I guess you were — and there may also have been something in there about you having worked with him, and that’s how you knew. Then you pivoted on your heel, got in your truck and drove away, and I never even had a chance to finish my sentence.


I will not describe how I felt as you drove away; instead, here are some of the things I thought about you:
• Rude, inconsiderate
• Abusive, abrupt

• Talks down at me, thinks he’s superior

• Explosive intermittent disorder (this is the modern diagnosis, I suffer from it too)

• Intolerant
• Must be hard to work with, being around a person so critical with a hair-trigger temper

• Doesn’t want to listen, close-minded

• Sociopath, only likes people who can help him out• No empathy with others… and so on. This is an incomplete list, but I’m sure you get the general drift.

As a result of that unfortunate meeting, I THOUGHT YOU WERE A REALLY FUCKED-UP PERSON, PERSONALLY, AND THE WAY YOU TREATED ME CAUSED ME TO HATE YOU. And I don’t like to hate things, it’s a waste of energy. But I do hate you, and I find I’ve hated you for 50 fucking years now. That probably says more about me than about you, and I admit I have anger management problems. But since then I’ve learned something important, and puzzling.

Somebody else gave you the same information, and you reacted differently to him than you did to me. So I think I’m justified in asking “What did he do right that I did wrong?” or, “What was the difference in Dr. Blair Irvine’s approach to me and this other person?”


Dr. Randall Wells, as I’m sure you’ve heard, has been an acquaintance of mine since we met in a marine biology class at Riverview High School in Sarasota in 1968 or ’69. I had a lot of social problems in high school, but Randy wasn’t one of them; he was just a nice, affable, intelligent guy, and he didn’t seem to get picked on much, so we talked a bit. Over the years, my esteem for him has only grown, and I now donate monthly a small amount, all I can afford in my current circumstances, to the SDRP, because I know that 90% of that money will go to benefit the dolphins of Sarasota Bay, and the other 10% to buy beer for the boat crew worn-out from chasing, netting, examining and logging them all day. (Just kidding!) So it is Randy’s compassion for the dolphins, and the excellence of his research, his personal friendliness toward me over time and a belief in acting locally, that make me want to donate to the splendid organization that you and Randy created together.


Now, here’s my problem, Dr. Irvine, and it consists of two words you may have heard before: COGNITIVE DISSONANCE.

You see, Randy is an exceptional person, and I do not see him mentoring, or collaborating, or getting papers published, with somebody who was rude to him, browbeat him, talked down to him, insulted his intelligence, and dismissed him with a wave of your hand, all of which you did to me that frosty March morning. When Randy came to you with John C. Lilly’s name on his lips — he proudly displayed a copy of Mind of the Dolphin on the SDRP podcast last week as his first dolphin book — you reacted differently, very differently, to him than you did to me.


Was it the fact that you were renting your house from his folks that made you feel indebted to them and caused you to moderate your self-righteous anger with the lad, or did I see a side of you you don’t show to others in your profession? The sociopathic side, the side that steps on unsung grad students to get research published, the side that curses the dolphins for struggling when you burn holes in their dorsal fins to tag them? The side that decided I WAS A NON-PERSON SO YOU COULD TREAT ME LIKE SHIT THAT MORNING BECAUSE I DIDN’T READ YOUR MIND AND REALIZE, SOMEHOW, BEFORE THE WORDS LEFT MY MOUTH, THAT ME SAYING DR. JOHN C. LILLY’S NAME WOULD TRIGGER YOU INTO A RAGE OF BARELY-CONTROLLED ANGER?


What was it, Dr. Irvine, that made you react differently to Randy than to me? A short-term circumstance, I hope, something like “Sorry, I hadn’t had breakfast that morning,” or “Sorry, I didn’t get laid the night before.” Those would be comprehensible, if not excuses. Something like “My mother died the day before,” that would be an excuse. I don’t know, and for 50 fucking years your behavior toward me that morning has been like a big grub, festering in my brain, and it doesn’t go away, and if it does, I always come back to it eventually.


What you did, I should point out, was also bad news from a scientific point of view. With Randy you were apparently able to hold a polite discussion and explain to him what was wrong with Lilly’s work. He listened, learned, and grew from it. Me, you told to fuck off, and I hate you for it.

So there’s my cognitive dissociation, Dr. Irvine: which human are you? I cannot make the two images align, or even overlap: are you a kind, nuturing scientist that gets along with his colleagues or the rude, abusive (yes, ABUSIVE, when did you stop beating your wife abusive), short-tempered person I encountered that morning? And more importantly, for reasons that apparently have nothing to do with you, WHY ME? When open scientific discussions such as I presumed we were having get SHUT DOWN because someone dropped a name he wasn’t supposed to, that’s not science, that’s prejudice and bigotry. Let me remind you, you never got a chance to explain your POV to me either, and if that wasn’t your fault, it sure as hell wasn’t mine.


So all in all, Dr. Irvine, I don’t think very well of you, but I allow that I might be mistaken, because Dr. Wells likes you, I mean, you are his mentor and everything, and I don’t think, as I have said, Randy would work for very long with somebody who abused him. I am quite confused as to who you really are, and I hope you see fit to clarify the situation for me, as I find it very difficult to go forward with my own work like this, unable to rectify two polar-opposite views of you. So please tell me, if you will, why I saw the unpleasant side of the distinguished scientist that morning, and why Randy did not.


I’ve decided not to critique the famous experiments with Simo that Randy filmed for you, although I will say, in passing, that dolphins do not in nature swim in 6′ deep donut-shaped pools, and any evidence acquired thereby can only be applied to the behavior of dolphins in the wild by a rather thinly stretched interpolation.


In closing, Dr. Irvine, I hope I have expressed myself clearly, and that you now know the reason for my impertinence in mentioning Dr. Lilly’s unspeakable name to you on that sorry morning. It WAS totally my fault that I failed to read your mind, and for that I can only offer sincere, if abject, apologies. Let me finally say to you the words that I have been wanting to say for 50 long, sad years: EAT SHIT AND DIE, YOU WORTHLESS WASTE OF PROTOPLASM! FUCK YOU AND THE HORSE YOU RODE IN ON. I THINK YOU’RE A BUNKO SCIENTIST, AND IF YOU WERE CRUEL TO ME, WHO ELSE WERE YOU CRUEL TO? WHAT OTHER NON-PERSONS DID YOU STEP ON TO GET WHERE YOU ARE? I am sure they remember the encounters, even if you don’t.


Thank you for reading this letter. I will continue to donate to the SDRP because I believe in and trust Randy, not you. I hope I have made myself clear, and have a really fucked-up day.

  
Most sincerely, Malcolm J. Brenner, author of Wet Goddess: Recollections of a Dolphin Lover and other books.

The “Road Soda” Interview: Good News/Bad News.

sideleap

WHAT IS YOUR STORY? $$ (Sarasota)

Compensation: $35

What is your story? Do you have an interesting life story, event that happened to you, or anything in-between? I will pay you for an interview to learn about your story and your interview will be put in a podcast. Please email for more info.
The above advertisement appeared in the Sarasota Craigslist on Oct. 16, but I didn’t notice it until Oct. 26. I don’t know why I was looking at “Gigs, Creative” — well, yes I do, I desperately needed money, but why in Sarasota, my old stomping grounds about 45 minutes north of here? I don’t know, but I read the above and immediately sent them the following message:
Yeah, I have an interesting story that ought to make a good podcast.
In 1971, while attending New College, I fell in love with a female dolphin who worked at an amusement park in Nokomis, Floridaland. And we made love. And then I lost her.
And I wrote and published a book about it, “Wet Goddess: Recollections of a Dolphin Lover,” which got made into a award-winning short film, “Dolphin Lover.”
If you’ve gotten this far, we might talk. Call me, (415) 640-****. I live in Port Charlotte.
The response was very rapid, a couple of hours:
Malcolm,

I have heard about your story and would love to interview you for the cast.
The show is called Road Soda and has been running a few years. We are small and have a small but loyal listener base. The show has a wide variety of topics and always aims to entertain.
We do our interviews over the phone using skype or whatsapp and usually run about an hour. When the interview is all done we will send you 35 dollars through venmo, paypal, zelle, what ever is best for you, as a thank you for your time.
Interview times are M-F evenings 7pm-9pm
If weekends are your only free time, we can work something out.
Let me know what day you are free this following week and we will schedule ASAP.

looking forward to your response!

Thank you for reaching out. 
I still didn’t have a name, but I had an interview!
The interviewer was Isaiah Cooper, who turned out to be a welcome change from the interviewers of the past. He wasn’t out to question my morality, he didn’t try to defame me or insult me, he’d actually watched Dolphin Lover like I suggested and he let me tell my tale my own way, asking questions that illuminated things. (His regular sidekick, Peter Something-or-other, wasn’t there for the interview.) Our talk lasted an hour, which is plenty long enough to discuss things, and I ended up want to meet him in person (although I haven’t). Altogether, a nice, straight-up kind of guy!
That’s the good news.
What’s the bad news? Well, here’s the interview: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/road-soda/id1028616849?ign-mpt=uo%3D4
I come on about 54 minutes in.
I defy you to listen to it and UNDERSTAND MORE THAN HALF OF WHAT I’M SAYING.
In other words, the audio is shit. I had a pair of earbuds with a built-in microphone, which I bought for $9.99 when my Apple earbuds crapped out, and I was using them for sound, never suspecting that it sounded like I was talking on a tin can and a string. I wish to hell Isaiah had enough technical expertise to tell me I didn’t sound good and ask if I had another microphone (I do, the Radio Shack shotgun mic I used to record Mel-Khyor with, but it’s a little trouble to set up… how much? Oh, about 45 seconds), but no, he just let me ramble on, so the interview is very difficult to listen to.
Well, I was expressing this problem to my daughter, who is knowledgeable about such things, and she said “I’ve got a Yeti mic here I bought for an interview and don’t use anymore, would you like it?” So she’s going to bring it out here next time she comes. And until then, I will use the Radio Shack shotgun mic, as it’s impedance almost exactly matches that of the computer, for any other interviews I may do.
Problem solved, I guess… except that you have to listen to this utterly crappy-sounding interview. If you want to. (BTW, Isaiah has paid me my $35, so we are cool there. I bought  a cup of coffee at Starbuck’s and left the change for the baristas to fight over.)

Another day, another podcast…

frontierBrenner

I’ll be appearing on “Uncle Tee’s Cool Pool Party,” a podcast at 8 p.m. EDST Monday on STLR Media in Sarasota. This is the same time slot as “The Twysted Tyrants Show” with Johnny Christ BayBay that I was on about a month ago, but Johnny is gone and it’s a new show. Host Cat Welch has promised me we’ll be able to talk about other things than my love affair with a dolphin, things like my family’s involvement with the crazy pseudo-science of the late Dr. Wilhelm Reich, the 20 years I spent practicing Wicca, the decade I spent reporting on the Navajos and Zunis, or my attempts to understand the elusive nature of the UFO, starting when I was a child. (Photo of me defending the First Amendment outside the trailer of the Farmington Daily Times in Shiprock, N.M. Photo by Chas Clifton.)

“Dolphin Lover” to play L.A. Film Festival

Dolphin-Lover-This-Man-Poster

The short film “Dolphin Lover,” about Malcolm J. Brenner’s relationship with Dolly the dolphin, will play at the prestigious 2015 Los Angeles Film Festival.  Screening time is 8:45 p.m. on Monday, June 15 at the Regal Cinemas Live as part of the Shorts Program 1.  For information about future screenings, please return to this web site.

Sarasota unRavel.us Interview

Short interview with Malcolm J. Brenner by Kat Dow of unRavel.us, a web site of the Sarasota Herald-Tribune newspaper.  Being where Brenner lived during the time, the early 1970’s, Sarasota is “ground zero” for the “Wet Goddess” story.  “Dolphin Lover” screened twice at the recent 2015 Sarasota Film Festival.  The film makes use of archival footage of Floridaland, the small theme park with a dolphin show in Nokomis which provided the setting for the book.  The location is today occupied by a housing development.

Sarasota Film Festival appearance

Malcolm J. Brenner will be appearing at a showing of Dolphin Lover at the Sarasota Film Festival, 9:45 p.m. Sunday, April 12.  The film will be shown as part of a package of short films being screened at the Hollywood Cinema in theater T12.  Director Kareem Tabsch will also be there.  Dolphin Lover will repeat as part of the same package on Thursday, April 16 at 10 p.m. in theater T10 with producer Joey Daoud in attendance.